| 2017 New York Film Critics Online Awards |
| Top 10 Films (Alphabetical order): |
| Call Me by Your Name | |
| Dunkirk | |
| The Florida Project | |
| Get Out | |
| I, Tonya | |
| Lady Bird | |
| Mudbound | |
| Phantom Thread | |
| The Post | |
| The Shape of Water |
| Best Film: |
| The Florida Project and Mudbound (tie) |
| Best Director: |
| Dee Rees - Mudbound |
| Best Cast: |
| Mudbound |
| Best Actor: |
| Gary Oldman - Darkest Hour |
| Best Actress: |
| Margot Robbie - I, Tonya |
| Best Supporting Actor: |
| Willem Dafoe - The Florida Project |
| Best Supporting Actress: |
| Allison Janney - I, Tonya |
| Best Screenplay: |
| Get Out - Jordan Peele |
| Best Cinematography: |
| The Shape of Water - Dan Laustsen |
| Best Film Music or Score: |
| Baby Driver - Steven Price and Kristen Lane |
| Best Foreign Language Film: |
| Aus dem Nichts (In the Fade) • Germany |
| Best Documentary: |
| Bombshell: The Hedy Lamarr Story |
| Best Animated Film: |
| Coco |
| Best Debut Director: |
| Jordan Peele - Get Out |
| Breakthrough Performer: |
| Timothée Chalamet - Call Me by Your Name |